Evidence over emotion. Process over prediction. Better decisions over better guesses.

By Steve Lowrie, CFA
Special to Financial Independence Hub
A few months ago, when I introduced this series I explained that sometimes the right decision does not produce the outcome you want. Disappointing results deserve scrutiny. However, they do not automatically establish that the initial decision was wrong.
A good example is the recent experience with bonds. Even over the past ten years, broad bond market returns have been barely positive and have not kept pace with inflation, which has tested investors’ patience. Bonds can also lose money when interest rates rise, as investors experienced in 2022. If bonds can disappoint on both return and stability, the question I sometimes get is: what are they doing in my portfolio?
It is a fair question, particularly for investors who expected bonds to provide dependable returns and stability and have found the recent experience disappointing.
Two things are worth noting before going further:
The first is that ten years is an arbitrary window. Move the starting date and the conclusion moves with it. Bonds have delivered positive returns in each of the three calendar years since 2022, so an investor measuring from the beginning of 2023 would describe a very different experience. We settle on ten years because it feels long enough to mean something, which is precisely why it is worth being careful about what we take from it.
The second is that bonds are only one part of a portfolio. Over the same period, equity returns ran well ahead of the expectations most financial plans were built on. For the majority of investors holding a balanced portfolio, the stronger equity returns more than made up for the weaker returns on bonds, which meant the portfolio as a whole outperformed what the plan was aiming for. If you are ahead of your planning objectives, a weak decade in bonds is a line item rather than a verdict.
A disappointing stretch is not a reason to abandon bonds. Their purpose is to help preserve capital, reduce portfolio volatility, and support planned cash flow needs. Equities provide the opportunity for long-term growth and compared with bonds and cash, have historically been the best asset class to outpace inflation over the long run. Keeping those goals clear is fundamental to building a properly diversified portfolio.
Why have bond returns been so disappointing?
For much of the period following the financial crisis of 2008 and 2009, interest rates were unusually low. Investors buying high-quality bonds were accepting very low yields. Inflation was also relatively low for much of that period, which limited the damage to purchasing power.
During COVID in 2020, yields fell even further. A five-year Government of Canada bond, for example, yielded less than 1% annually. Investors buying at those yields were accepting a very modest return for the next five years. In the aftermath of COVID, inflation accelerated sharply in 2021 and 2022, followed by a substantial rise in bond yields. Bond prices and interest rates move in opposite directions: when interest rates rise, prices fall, and when they fall, prices rise. Generally, the longer the remaining term of a bond, the greater the price sensitivity to changing interest rates. Existing bonds are repriced up or down to reflect the yields available in the market.
In 2022, Canadian bond investors experienced close to a perfect storm of very low income and falling prices. The result was the worst calendar year in the history of the index, which begins in 1980, and roughly three times worse than the previous record.
That previous record was set in 1994, and the comparison is instructive. Both years were interest rate shocks. The difference is that investors in 1994 were collecting roughly six per cent in interest income while prices fell, and that income cushioned the damage. In 2022, they were collecting well under one per cent, because that is what yields had fallen to during COVID. The same kind of shock produced a far worse outcome, and the variable that explains it is the starting yield.
This is why it is important to focus on a bond’s total return, which includes both the income received and any change in its price. Looking only at the interest payment misses part of the result, and focusing on income rather than total return can lead investors off track. I covered these mechanics in six enduring insights for fixed income investing.
The negative returns in 2022 explain much of the disappointing returns over the past ten years.
There is a further point that tends to get lost, because most of the coverage of rising interest rates focuses on borrowers. Higher rates are genuinely difficult if you are carrying a mortgage or financing a business. If you are investing in cash and bonds, they are good news, because the rates available on high-quality bonds today are far better than anything on offer through those years of near zero rates.
The experience of 2022 should not be dismissed. However, those past returns reflect previous starting conditions and provide an incomplete basis for deciding what to own today.
What is the role of bonds in a diversified portfolio?
Bonds serve three main purposes: preserving capital, reducing overall portfolio volatility, and supporting planned cash flow needs.
The first purpose is to help preserve your capital. Money set aside for stability and upcoming spending should be invested with a low risk of loss and confidence that it will be available when needed. That is why the quality of the bonds and the length of time until they mature matter.
As a reminder, when you purchase an individual bond, you know the purchase price, the maturity date, the amount repayable at maturity, and the interest payments along the way. Those known amounts allow you to calculate its expected return. Choosing a financially strong issuer, such as the Government of Canada, reduces the risk that payments will not be made as promised. However, if you sell a bond before maturity, the market price may be higher or lower than what you paid, changing the return you actually receive.
Most conventional bond funds do not have a single maturity date. They hold a collection of bonds whose market prices fluctuate; however, high-quality holdings and shorter maturities help to limit those fluctuations.
The second purpose is to reduce overall portfolio volatility. Historically, a portfolio containing high-quality bonds has fluctuated significantly less than an all-equity portfolio.
That matters because an investment strategy only works if it is one you can stick with. A portfolio that looks attractive on paper but causes you to sell during a decline is poorly matched to your temperament. The bond allocation helps keep the overall risk at a level you can afford and tolerate.
The third purpose is to support planned cash flow needs. If you draw cash flow from your portfolio, your next withdrawal should not depend entirely on what equities happen to be worth that month.
Cash and shorter-term, high-quality bonds provide a reserve for spending. Accepting a lower expected return on that money is a deliberate trade-off that reduces your dependence on equity markets for near term needs.
Why did stocks and bonds both lose money in 2022?
The sharp rise in inflation and interest rates hurt bond prices while also putting pressure on equity valuations. As a result, bonds did not provide the offset many investors expected when stocks fell.
Before 2022, the previous calendar year in which both Canadian stocks and Canadian bonds delivered negative total returns was 1994. Although this combination is rare, it is a reminder that diversification reduces risk without eliminating the possibility of losses across different investments at the same time.
Why use short term bonds to preserve capital and reduce volatility?
Shorter-term, high-quality bonds generally fluctuate less when interest rates change. For the goals of preserving principal and reducing volatility, maturities of five years or less keep the focus on stability.
Academic research identifies two important sources of additional expected return in bonds beyond cash. The term premium compensates investors for accepting more exposure to changes in interest rates, generally through longer maturities. The credit premium compensates investors for accepting a greater risk that a borrower will not meet its obligations. Neither premium is guaranteed; however, historically both premiums have been positive and there is no reason to assume this will change. Continue Reading…








